You know your law is absolute garbage when even liberal justices Sotomayor and Kagan vote against you. The Supreme Court crushed Colorado’s so-called “conversion therapy” ban 8-1 on Monday, ruling that the state had no business threatening to destroy a Christian counselor’s career because Democrats didn’t like the words coming out of her mouth.
Eight to one! Ketanji Brown Jackson was the only justice willing to die on that hill. Somewhere in Denver, Governor Jared Polis is staring at his framed signing-ceremony photo and wondering where it all went wrong.
Kaley Chiles is a licensed counselor from Colorado Springs. She doesn’t shock anyone. She doesn’t prescribe drugs. She doesn’t strap teenagers to tables and zap them like some villain in a B-movie. She talks to people — willing clients who walk through her door voluntarily, many of them referred by their own churches. That’s it. Talk therapy rooted in her Christian faith.
Colorado Democrats decided that certain *words*, spoken privately between a licensed professional and her willing clients, constituted “harmful medical treatment” that the state needed to stamp out. Polis — the first openly gay governor in the country — signed this censorship bill into law in 2019 and practically threw himself a parade over it.
Justice Gorsuch, writing for the massive majority, dropped the hammer: “Colorado’s law addressing conversion therapy does not just ban physical interventions. In cases like this, it censors speech based on viewpoint.” Then he twisted the knife even further, writing that “censorious governments throughout history have believed the same” when they claimed crushing speech was necessary for the public good.
Getting compared to history’s censors by an 8-1 Supreme Court — that’s going to look fantastic on Polis’s presidential campaign brochure. (Oh wait, he doesn’t have one of those anymore, does he?)
Now pay attention to the scam Colorado was running, because this is where your blood should start boiling. Under this law, a licensed counselor could talk a confused fourteen-year-old *into* a gender transition — puberty blockers, hormones, the whole catastrophe — and the state applauded. But if that same counselor said, “Hey, maybe we should slow down and explore whether these feelings might resolve on their own,” she faced a $5,000 fine and the end of her career.
Read that again. Steering a kid toward irreversible medical procedures? Heroic. Suggesting they pump the brakes? Criminal conduct.
Justice Alito called it exactly what it was during oral arguments — “blatant viewpoint discrimination.” A counselor could cheer on a teenager’s decision to reject their biological sex. But helping a teenager who *wanted* to feel comfortable in their own body? That made you an outlaw in Jared Polis’s Colorado.
Democrats picked the only acceptable opinion and threatened to destroy anyone who held a different one. That’s not a health policy. That’s a protection racket.
And here’s the part that really exposes what frauds these people are — the law already exempted unlicensed religious ministers from the ban. So Pastor Dave down at the community church could counsel teenagers on these exact topics all day long. No license, no training, no problem. But Kaley Chiles, who holds a master’s degree in clinical mental health and actually *knows what she’s doing*, faced punishment for offering the same conversations. Why? Because she had a license the state could threaten to revoke.
Democrats trusted random unlicensed clergy over a trained professional — not because they cared about kids, but because they had no leverage over the clergy. The quiet part out loud.
The lone dissenter, Ketanji Brown Jackson, read her dissent from the bench like she was delivering a eulogy for common sense. She warned that the ruling “opens a dangerous can of worms” and argued that states should be free to regulate “harmful medical treatments” even when those treatments consist entirely of… words. By Jackson’s logic, every therapist in America is practicing “medicine via speech” and the government owns every syllable. Brilliant legal reasoning from the woman who couldn’t define “woman” during her own confirmation hearing.
The Trevor Project immediately clutched its pearls, calling the ruling “a tragic step backward” that will “put young lives at risk.” Spare us. A counselor having a voluntary conversation with a willing client whose parents approved isn’t putting anyone at risk. You know what actually endangers kids? Telling every confused teenager that the only acceptable answer is a lifetime of cross-sex hormones and irreversible surgery — and then destroying every professional who dares suggest otherwise.
This is what Democrats do, every single time. They wrap raw censorship in a “protecting children” bow, weaponize licensing boards and regulatory agencies against anyone who dissents, and then act shocked — *shocked!* — when a court tells them they can’t do that. Colorado’s law was never about preventing abuse. Abuse was already illegal everywhere. The law existed so Democrats could point a gun at every licensed counselor in the state and say, “Agree with us on gender and sexuality or we end your career.”
Eight Supreme Court justices — including the liberal ones — saw right through it. Kaley Chiles gets to keep talking to her clients, Jared Polis gets to keep his signing-ceremony photo, and the rest of us get a reminder that when Democrats tell you a law is “for the children,” you should read the fine print with both eyes open.
—
